Nick Jonas and Adrienne Warren's 'The Last Five Years' Falls Short on Broadway
Image: Sara Krulwich/The New York Times

Nick Jonas and Adrienne Warren's 'The Last Five Years' Falls Short on Broadway

FusePop swoosh logo

A Promising Revival Struggles to Capture the Musical's Emotional Depth

AI Summary generated by Patrick Diola @ FusePop
4/8/2025

Nick Jonas and Adrienne Warren's 'The Last Five Years' Falls Short on Broadway

The highly anticipated Broadway revival of Jason Robert Brown's beloved musical 'The Last Five Years' has arrived, featuring pop star Nick Jonas and acclaimed actress Adrienne Warren. Despite the star power, the production struggles to breathe new life into the complex, non-linear love story.

The musical, which chronicles the rise and fall of a young couple's relationship, is known for its unique storytelling structure. Cathy (Warren) tells her story backward, while Jamie (Jonas) moves chronologically forward, creating a poignant exploration of love, ambition, and personal growth.

Key challenges in this revival include:

  • Lack of chemistry between the lead performers
  • Uneven vocal performances
  • Staging that feels somewhat static and uninspired

While both Jonas and Warren are talented performers, they seem to struggle with the nuanced emotional landscape of their characters. The production's staging appears to muddy the intricate emotional threads that make the original work so compelling.

Critics and theater enthusiasts have noted that the revival, despite its potential, fails to capture the raw vulnerability and intimate storytelling that made the original production so memorable. The musical's complex emotional journey requires a delicate touch that this current production seems to miss.

For fans of contemporary musical theater, this revival of 'The Last Five Years' offers an interesting but ultimately disappointing interpretation of a beloved work.

Related Articles on FusePop

For Shailene Woodley, Every Day Is Christmas
Theater

For Shailene Woodley, Every Day Is Christmas

How to Handle a Friend's Disappointing Performance Gracefully
Theater

How to Handle a Friend's Disappointing Performance Gracefully

British World War II Deception Play 'Operation Mincemeat' Conquers Broadway
Theater

British World War II Deception Play 'Operation Mincemeat' Conquers Broadway

Sadie Sink Reimagines a Classic: 'John Proctor Is the Villain'
Theater

Sadie Sink Reimagines a Classic: 'John Proctor Is the Villain'

Wine in the Wilderness: A Powerful Exploration of Black Identity
Theater

Wine in the Wilderness: A Powerful Exploration of Black Identity

From TV Hit to Broadway: The 'Smash' Song Transformation
Theater

From TV Hit to Broadway: The 'Smash' Song Transformation

Vaccine Debate Turns Comedy: 'Eureka Day' Skewers Modern Discourse
Theater

Vaccine Debate Turns Comedy: 'Eureka Day' Skewers Modern Discourse

Athol Fugard: A Voice for Human Dignity in Apartheid's Shadow
Theater

Athol Fugard: A Voice for Human Dignity in Apartheid's Shadow

Lost in Translation: A Journey Through Language and Identity
Theater

Lost in Translation: A Journey Through Language and Identity

Toxic Masculinity Unmasked: How 'Manhunt' Reveals Male Vulnerability
Theater

Toxic Masculinity Unmasked: How 'Manhunt' Reveals Male Vulnerability

Paul Mescal Electrifies in Radical 'Streetcar' Revival
Theater

Paul Mescal Electrifies in Radical 'Streetcar' Revival

Starving Class: A Theatrical Feast That Leaves Audiences Hungry
Theater

Starving Class: A Theatrical Feast That Leaves Audiences Hungry

Mind Magic: Vinny DePonto's Quest to Restore Wonder
Theater

Mind Magic: Vinny DePonto's Quest to Restore Wonder

Whitney White: A Rising Star Commanding Stages Everywhere
Theater

Whitney White: A Rising Star Commanding Stages Everywhere

Broadway's Newest Spectacle: Nicole Scherzinger's Towering Presence in 'Sunset Boulevard'
Theater

Broadway's Newest Spectacle: Nicole Scherzinger's Towering Presence in 'Sunset Boulevard'

Diane Paulus: Transforming Theater from the Director's Chair
Theater

Diane Paulus: Transforming Theater from the Director's Chair

From Child Stars to Broadway Comeback: Nick Jonas and Sadie Sink's Theatrical Journey
Arts

From Child Stars to Broadway Comeback: Nick Jonas and Sadie Sink's Theatrical Journey

Beyond the Script: The Physical Challenge of 'Sumo'
Theater

Beyond the Script: The Physical Challenge of 'Sumo'

Shakespeare's Epic Tale Reimagined: 'Henry IV' Comes Alive on Stage
Theater

Shakespeare's Epic Tale Reimagined: 'Henry IV' Comes Alive on Stage

Operation Mincemeat: The Ingenious WWII Deception That Changed History
Theater

Operation Mincemeat: The Ingenious WWII Deception That Changed History

Stranger Things Invades Broadway: A Supernatural Prequel Comes to Life
Theater

Stranger Things Invades Broadway: A Supernatural Prequel Comes to Life

Threads of Memory: 'The Blood Quilt' Weaves a Powerful Narrative
Arts

Threads of Memory: 'The Blood Quilt' Weaves a Powerful Narrative

David Greenspan's Captivating Performance: A Must-See Theatrical Experience
Theater

David Greenspan's Captivating Performance: A Must-See Theatrical Experience

Idina Menzel Soars in Powerful Broadway Performance of 'Redwood'
Theater

Idina Menzel Soars in Powerful Broadway Performance of 'Redwood'

The Greatest Showman Musical Comes to British Stages
Theater

The Greatest Showman Musical Comes to British Stages

Smash: A Musical Comedy Triumph Returns to the Stage
Theater

Smash: A Musical Comedy Triumph Returns to the Stage

Jonathan Larson's Legacy Lives On: A New Off-Broadway Tribute
Arts

Jonathan Larson's Legacy Lives On: A New Off-Broadway Tribute

Hollywood Legends Honor James Earl Jones at Touching Memorial
Theater

Hollywood Legends Honor James Earl Jones at Touching Memorial

Bridget Jones Fans, Meet Your New Romantic Comedy Crush
Movies

Bridget Jones Fans, Meet Your New Romantic Comedy Crush

Survival at Sea: When Disaster Strikes
Arts

Survival at Sea: When Disaster Strikes

Rediscovering Forgotten Playwrights: A New Theatrical Renaissance
Theater

Rediscovering Forgotten Playwrights: A New Theatrical Renaissance

Behind the Scenes: The Dance Maestro of 'The Lion King'
Dance

Behind the Scenes: The Dance Maestro of 'The Lion King'

Must-Watch TV: 'The Residence' and Top Shows This Week
Television

Must-Watch TV: 'The Residence' and Top Shows This Week

Cynthia Erivo: Bringing Depth and Humanity to Every Role
Theater

Cynthia Erivo: Bringing Depth and Humanity to Every Role

Operation Mincemeat: A Family's Wartime Secret Unveiled
Theater

Operation Mincemeat: A Family's Wartime Secret Unveiled

Off Broadway Workers Unite: A New Era of Labor Rights
Theater

Off Broadway Workers Unite: A New Era of Labor Rights

Mitzi Gaynor, Star of 'South Pacific,' Dies at 93
Theater

Mitzi Gaynor, Star of 'South Pacific,' Dies at 93

Boop! The Musical: A Nostalgic Leap from Cartoon to Broadway
Theater

Boop! The Musical: A Nostalgic Leap from Cartoon to Broadway

‘Tammy Faye’ and ‘Cinderella’ Were Hits in London but Failed on Broadway
Theater

‘Tammy Faye’ and ‘Cinderella’ Were Hits in London but Failed on Broadway

Powerhouse Performances Electrify Broadway's 'Glengarry Glen Ross'
Television

Powerhouse Performances Electrify Broadway's 'Glengarry Glen Ross'

Sadie Sink Makes Broadway Return in New Drama
Theater

Sadie Sink Makes Broadway Return in New Drama

From Cuba to Broadway: The Magical Journey of Buena Vista Social Club
Theater

From Cuba to Broadway: The Magical Journey of Buena Vista Social Club

Sadie Sink Takes Broadway Stage in Powerful New Drama
Theater

Sadie Sink Takes Broadway Stage in Powerful New Drama

Adam Driver Takes Center Stage in 'Hold On to Me Darling'
Theater

Adam Driver Takes Center Stage in 'Hold On to Me Darling'

Why ‘Show Boat’ Is America’s Most Enduring, Unstable Musical
Theater

Why ‘Show Boat’ Is America’s Most Enduring, Unstable Musical

The Playwright's Dilemma: Navigating the Midcareer Maze
Theater

The Playwright's Dilemma: Navigating the Midcareer Maze

A Russian Journalist's Fight for Truth Echoes America's Political Moment
Theater

A Russian Journalist's Fight for Truth Echoes America's Political Moment

Phylicia Rashad: A Legacy of Purpose and Inspiration
Theater

Phylicia Rashad: A Legacy of Purpose and Inspiration

Elf on Broadway: Grey Henson Shines as Buddy
Theater

Elf on Broadway: Grey Henson Shines as Buddy

Grangeville: A Provocative Exploration of Family Complexity
Theater

Grangeville: A Provocative Exploration of Family Complexity

Must-See Broadway Shows Coming This Fall Season
Theater

Must-See Broadway Shows Coming This Fall Season

Breaking Barriers: A Trans Rabbi's Journey of Faith and Identity
Theater

Breaking Barriers: A Trans Rabbi's Journey of Faith and Identity

Behind the Magic: How 'Wicked' Became a Broadway Phenomenon
Books

Behind the Magic: How 'Wicked' Became a Broadway Phenomenon

Richard Foreman: Avant-Garde Theater's Visionary Passes Away
Theater

Richard Foreman: Avant-Garde Theater's Visionary Passes Away

Meryl Streep and Goldie Hawn Bring 'Death Becomes Her' Magic to Broadway
Theater

Meryl Streep and Goldie Hawn Bring 'Death Becomes Her' Magic to Broadway

Raygun Shuts Down Musical Inspired by Her Jeered Olympic Breaking
Theater

Raygun Shuts Down Musical Inspired by Her Jeered Olympic Breaking

The Comédie-Française: A Living Monument of French Theater
Theater

The Comédie-Française: A Living Monument of French Theater

York Theater Director Steps Down Following Controversial Diversity Remarks
Theater

York Theater Director Steps Down Following Controversial Diversity Remarks

Mimi Hines, Broadway Star Who Followed Barbra Streisand in 'Funny Girl,' Dies at 91
Theater

Mimi Hines, Broadway Star Who Followed Barbra Streisand in 'Funny Girl,' Dies at 91

Review: In ‘Eureka Day,’ Holding Space for Those You Hate
Theater

Review: In ‘Eureka Day,’ Holding Space for Those You Hate

Behind the Curtain: A Week in the Chaotic World of Experimental Theater
Theater

Behind the Curtain: A Week in the Chaotic World of Experimental Theater

Love Songs: The Perfect Anniversary Playlist
Music

Love Songs: The Perfect Anniversary Playlist

Athol Fugard: A Voice Against Apartheid's Darkness
Theater

Athol Fugard: A Voice Against Apartheid's Darkness

Bad Kreyòl' Theater Review
Theater

Bad Kreyòl' Theater Review

Stage Crew Strike Ends: Atlantic Theater Reaches Breakthrough Agreement
Theater

Stage Crew Strike Ends: Atlantic Theater Reaches Breakthrough Agreement

Nature Theater's Dance Revolution: Where Movement Speaks Louder Than Words
Theater

Nature Theater's Dance Revolution: Where Movement Speaks Louder Than Words

Behind the Scenes: Capturing Authentic College Life in 'All Nighter'
Theater

Behind the Scenes: Capturing Authentic College Life in 'All Nighter'

Death Becomes Her: A Darkly Comic Exploration of Immortality
Arts

Death Becomes Her: A Darkly Comic Exploration of Immortality

Les Misérables Makes Historic Return to Paris's Théâtre du Châtelet
Theater

Les Misérables Makes Historic Return to Paris's Théâtre du Châtelet

9 Best Theater Moments of 2024
Theater

9 Best Theater Moments of 2024

Orville Peck Reveals Unmasked Performance in Broadway's 'Cabaret'
Fashion & Style

Orville Peck Reveals Unmasked Performance in Broadway's 'Cabaret'

ABBA Magic Returns: 'Mamma Mia!' Broadway Revival Set for Summer
Theater

ABBA Magic Returns: 'Mamma Mia!' Broadway Revival Set for Summer

Claire van Kampen, Pioneering Musical Director and Playwright, Dies at 71
Theater

Claire van Kampen, Pioneering Musical Director and Playwright, Dies at 71

Tony Awards 2024: Cynthia Erivo Takes Center Stage as Host
Theater

Tony Awards 2024: Cynthia Erivo Takes Center Stage as Host

Love Spices Up at Eritrean Restaurant
Love

Love Spices Up at Eritrean Restaurant

Broadway Legends Reunite: 'South Pacific' Cast Returns for Charity
Fashion & Style

Broadway Legends Reunite: 'South Pacific' Cast Returns for Charity

The Last of Us: Your Essential Season 2 Refresh
Arts

The Last of Us: Your Essential Season 2 Refresh

Wisdom in Verse: Bob Dylan's Profound Reflections on Life and Death
Theater

Wisdom in Verse: Bob Dylan's Profound Reflections on Life and Death

From Heartbreak to Triumph: Brandon Uranowitz's 'Ragtime' Journey
Arts

From Heartbreak to Triumph: Brandon Uranowitz's 'Ragtime' Journey

Denzel Washington's Transformative Journey in 'The Interview'
Theater

Denzel Washington's Transformative Journey in 'The Interview'

Stage Spotlight: 8 Must-See Shows Captivating Theater Critics
Theater

Stage Spotlight: 8 Must-See Shows Captivating Theater Critics

Navigating Racial Tensions: A Florida Play Challenges Segregation Narratives
Theater

Navigating Racial Tensions: A Florida Play Challenges Segregation Narratives

Jason Laks Takes the Helm at Broadway League
Theater

Jason Laks Takes the Helm at Broadway League

Constitution Play Crosses Borders with Creative Twist
Theater

Constitution Play Crosses Borders with Creative Twist

Les Histrioniques: A Bold Theatrical Revolution
Theater

Les Histrioniques: A Bold Theatrical Revolution

A Day in the Life: Chris Perfetti's Sunday Rituals
Theater

A Day in the Life: Chris Perfetti's Sunday Rituals

Theater Legend Takes Over Second Stage Space
Theater

Theater Legend Takes Over Second Stage Space

Shocking Abortion Scene in 'The Years' Triggers Intense Audience Reactions
Theater

Shocking Abortion Scene in 'The Years' Triggers Intense Audience Reactions

From Titans to Theater: Why 'Attack on Titan' Could Pioneer Anime-Broadway Fusion
Theater

From Titans to Theater: Why 'Attack on Titan' Could Pioneer Anime-Broadway Fusion

Cultural Loss: NYC Theater's Artistic Freedom Curtailed by Church Intervention
Theater

Cultural Loss: NYC Theater's Artistic Freedom Curtailed by Church Intervention

Broadway's Armstrong Revival: 6 Timeless Satchmo Classics
Theater

Broadway's Armstrong Revival: 6 Timeless Satchmo Classics

The Dark Side of All-Nighters: More Harm Than Help
Theater

The Dark Side of All-Nighters: More Harm Than Help

'Hell's Kitchen' Triumphs at Grammy Awards
Arts

'Hell's Kitchen' Triumphs at Grammy Awards

Othello and Iago: A Toxic Dance of Manipulation and Betrayal
Theater

Othello and Iago: A Toxic Dance of Manipulation and Betrayal

The Mothers on Broadway Are Finally More Than Monsters
Theater

The Mothers on Broadway Are Finally More Than Monsters

Beyond the Green: Wicked Alumnae Share Life Lessons from Shiz University
Theater

Beyond the Green: Wicked Alumnae Share Life Lessons from Shiz University

Brooklyn's New Magic Hub: Where Close-Up Illusions Come Alive
Theater

Brooklyn's New Magic Hub: Where Close-Up Illusions Come Alive

Denzel Washington and Jake Gyllenhaal: A Riveting Dance of Power in 'Othello'
Theater

Denzel Washington and Jake Gyllenhaal: A Riveting Dance of Power in 'Othello'

George Clooney's Powerful Tribute to Journalistic Courage
Theater

George Clooney's Powerful Tribute to Journalistic Courage

TV Roundup: 'The White Lotus' Returns and 9 Must-Watch Shows
Television

TV Roundup: 'The White Lotus' Returns and 9 Must-Watch Shows