Tale of Two Tastes: Cafe Kestrel & Cocina Consuelo

Tale of Two Tastes: Cafe Kestrel & Cocina Consuelo

FusePop swoosh logo

A Culinary Journey Through Contemporary American and Authentic Mexican Cuisine

AI Summary generated by Patrick Diola @ FusePop
1/15/2025

Tale of Two Tastes: Cafe Kestrel & Cocina Consuelo

In the heart of downtown, two distinct culinary experiences await food enthusiasts. Cafe Kestrel, with its modern American approach, and Cocina Consuelo, offering authentic Mexican cuisine, present a fascinating study in contrasts while both delivering exceptional dining experiences.

Cafe Kestrel shines with its contemporary take on American classics. The industrial-chic setting, complete with exposed brick walls and pendant lighting, creates an sophisticated yet welcoming atmosphere. Their standout dish, the maple-glazed duck breast with roasted root vegetables ($32), exemplifies their commitment to elevating familiar flavors. The carefully curated wine list and craft cocktail menu further enhance the dining experience.

Just three blocks away, Cocina Consuelo transports diners to the heart of Mexico. This family-owned establishment radiates warmth through both its decor and service. The hand-painted tiles and vibrant murals set the stage for an authentic experience. Their mole poblano ($24) is a revelation, featuring a complex sauce that takes two days to prepare. The house-made tortillas and extensive selection of mezcal demonstrate their dedication to authenticity.

Both restaurants excel in their respective cuisines while maintaining distinct personalities. Cafe Kestrel's service is polished and professional, while Cocina Consuelo offers a more intimate, family-style experience. Price points are comparable, with dinner for two ranging from $80-120 at both establishments.

Whether you're in the mood for refined American cuisine or authentic Mexican flavors, both restaurants deliver memorable dining experiences that showcase the best of their respective culinary traditions. Reservations are recommended for both, particularly during weekend dinner service.

Related Articles on FusePop

Party Planning: When the Feast Matters Most
Dining & Wine

Party Planning: When the Feast Matters Most

Sweet and Sour, Festive and Fast
Dining & Wine

Sweet and Sour, Festive and Fast

Spice Up Your Winter: Warming Dishes to Beat the Cold
Dining & Wine

Spice Up Your Winter: Warming Dishes to Beat the Cold

Bagel Mods: The Underground World of Extreme Bagel Customization
Dining & Wine

Bagel Mods: The Underground World of Extreme Bagel Customization

The Perfect Marriage: Peanut Butter Meets Chocolate Cookie Bar
Dining & Wine

The Perfect Marriage: Peanut Butter Meets Chocolate Cookie Bar

Master the Perfect Stir Fry Chicken: Pro Techniques Revealed
Dining & Wine

Master the Perfect Stir Fry Chicken: Pro Techniques Revealed

Truly Just Divine Weeknight Tantanmen
Dining & Wine

Truly Just Divine Weeknight Tantanmen

The Perfect Takeout for a Night In
Dining & Wine

The Perfect Takeout for a Night In

Sourdough Waffles
Dining & Wine

Sourdough Waffles

A Superb, Speedy Chicken
Dining & Wine

A Superb, Speedy Chicken

It’s Time for Nutella Tres Leches Cake
Dining & Wine

It’s Time for Nutella Tres Leches Cake

Thanksgiving 2024: Fresh Recipes That Will Wow Your Guests
Dining & Wine

Thanksgiving 2024: Fresh Recipes That Will Wow Your Guests

Thanksgiving Prep: Your Ultimate Guide to a Stress-Free Feast
Dining & Wine

Thanksgiving Prep: Your Ultimate Guide to a Stress-Free Feast

Canlis Founders Mark and Brian Canlis Announce Separation of Business Paths
Dining & Wine

Canlis Founders Mark and Brian Canlis Announce Separation of Business Paths

Thanksgiving Essentials: Mastering the Perfect Holiday Feast
Dining & Wine

Thanksgiving Essentials: Mastering the Perfect Holiday Feast

Melissa Clark's Thanksgiving Side Dish Magic: Elevating Your Holiday Feast
Dining & Wine

Melissa Clark's Thanksgiving Side Dish Magic: Elevating Your Holiday Feast

Chicken and Lentils Soup
Dining & Wine

Chicken and Lentils Soup

Vegetarian Lasagna, Hand-Pulled Noodles and Pupusas
Dining & Wine

Vegetarian Lasagna, Hand-Pulled Noodles and Pupusas

NYC's Ultimate Bagel Guide: Where to Find the Best Rings of Glory
Dining & Wine

NYC's Ultimate Bagel Guide: Where to Find the Best Rings of Glory

Comforting Indian Dinner Recipes: Mattar Paneer and Beyond
Dining & Wine

Comforting Indian Dinner Recipes: Mattar Paneer and Beyond

Sheet-Pan Magic: Ottolenghi's Vibrant Twist on Weeknight Chicken
Dining & Wine

Sheet-Pan Magic: Ottolenghi's Vibrant Twist on Weeknight Chicken

Reclaiming Joy: Crafting the Ultimate Solo Saturday
Dining & Wine

Reclaiming Joy: Crafting the Ultimate Solo Saturday

Plant-Based Beef Battle: NYC Restaurant vs. Texas Rancher
Dining & Wine

Plant-Based Beef Battle: NYC Restaurant vs. Texas Rancher

From Small Restaurant to Fast Food Empire: The Origins of Panda Express
Dining & Wine

From Small Restaurant to Fast Food Empire: The Origins of Panda Express

Torrisi: Where New York City Becomes Culinary Poetry
Dining & Wine

Torrisi: Where New York City Becomes Culinary Poetry

Quick & Delicious: Roasted Chicken Thighs with Hot Honey and Lime
Dining & Wine

Quick & Delicious: Roasted Chicken Thighs with Hot Honey and Lime

Joe's Pizza: The Late-Night Haven for Saturday Night Live's Cast
Dining & Wine

Joe's Pizza: The Late-Night Haven for Saturday Night Live's Cast

Election Day Comfort: Brown Butter Cookie Recipe
Dining & Wine

Election Day Comfort: Brown Butter Cookie Recipe

Junior's Cheesecake: The Ultimate New York Dessert Tradition
Dining & Wine

Junior's Cheesecake: The Ultimate New York Dessert Tradition

Milk's Remarkable Transformation: A 2025 Revolution
Dining & Wine

Milk's Remarkable Transformation: A 2025 Revolution

Master the Art of Steak au Poivre: A Classic French Culinary Delight
Dining & Wine

Master the Art of Steak au Poivre: A Classic French Culinary Delight

Zesty Lemon-Pepper Tofu: A Vegetarian Delight
Dining & Wine

Zesty Lemon-Pepper Tofu: A Vegetarian Delight

Cookbook Throws: A Tasty New Mardi Gras Tradition
Dining & Wine

Cookbook Throws: A Tasty New Mardi Gras Tradition

Jam-Filled Bundt Cake: A Delightful Twist on Classic Desserts
Dining & Wine

Jam-Filled Bundt Cake: A Delightful Twist on Classic Desserts

Brighten Your Winter Days with a Delicious Strawberry Smoothie
Dining & Wine

Brighten Your Winter Days with a Delicious Strawberry Smoothie

Yogurt Safety 101: How Long Can It Really Sit Out?
Dining & Wine

Yogurt Safety 101: How Long Can It Really Sit Out?

Culinary Crescendo: A Rising Star in NYC's Dining Scene
Dining & Wine

Culinary Crescendo: A Rising Star in NYC's Dining Scene

Slurp & Savor: The Ultimate Guide to New Orleans' Oyster Scene
Dining & Wine

Slurp & Savor: The Ultimate Guide to New Orleans' Oyster Scene

Celebrating Lunar New Year with a Comforting Chicken Curry
Dining & Wine

Celebrating Lunar New Year with a Comforting Chicken Curry

Momofuku Ando: The Unsung Hero of Global Cuisine
Dining & Wine

Momofuku Ando: The Unsung Hero of Global Cuisine

Culinary Delights: Mastering Three Irresistible Dishes
Dining & Wine

Culinary Delights: Mastering Three Irresistible Dishes

Crispy Rice: The Culinary Trend Taking Kitchens by Storm
Dining & Wine

Crispy Rice: The Culinary Trend Taking Kitchens by Storm

Cheese Dreams: The Ultimate Thanksgiving Side Dish for 2024
Dining & Wine

Cheese Dreams: The Ultimate Thanksgiving Side Dish for 2024

Blackened Salmon: A Culinary Fire Dance of Flavor
Dining & Wine

Blackened Salmon: A Culinary Fire Dance of Flavor

5 Mouthwatering Thanksgiving Pie Recipes That Will Steal the Show
Dining & Wine

5 Mouthwatering Thanksgiving Pie Recipes That Will Steal the Show

Sesame Salmon Bowl: A Delicious Healthy Meal That Feels Like an Indulgence
Dining & Wine

Sesame Salmon Bowl: A Delicious Healthy Meal That Feels Like an Indulgence

Gnocchi Shines With Sausage and Peppers
Dining & Wine

Gnocchi Shines With Sausage and Peppers

The Stunning Cake That Anyone Can Bake
Dining & Wine

The Stunning Cake That Anyone Can Bake

Chili: The Heartwarming Dish That Conquers Every Comfort Food Craving
Dining & Wine

Chili: The Heartwarming Dish That Conquers Every Comfort Food Craving

Lazy Daisy Cake: The Simplest Dessert You'll Ever Make
Dining & Wine

Lazy Daisy Cake: The Simplest Dessert You'll Ever Make

French Onion Pasta: The Comfort Food Mashup You Didn't Know You Needed
Dining & Wine

French Onion Pasta: The Comfort Food Mashup You Didn't Know You Needed

Simply Having a Wonderful Weeknight Dinner
Dining & Wine

Simply Having a Wonderful Weeknight Dinner

Sausage and Peppers: A Delicious Dinner Hack with Mediterranean Flair
Dining & Wine

Sausage and Peppers: A Delicious Dinner Hack with Mediterranean Flair

Shrimp Cocktail Prices: What Consumers Need to Know
Dining & Wine

Shrimp Cocktail Prices: What Consumers Need to Know

The Decline of Restaurant Doggy Bags: A Sustainable Shift?
Dining & Wine

The Decline of Restaurant Doggy Bags: A Sustainable Shift?

Royal Recipes: Meghan Markle's Delightful Spring Culinary Creations
Dining & Wine

Royal Recipes: Meghan Markle's Delightful Spring Culinary Creations

Dining Out Defies Economic Odds: Restaurants Thrive Despite Inflation
Dining & Wine

Dining Out Defies Economic Odds: Restaurants Thrive Despite Inflation

Crab Rangoon: From Classic Appetizer to Culinary Inspiration
Dining & Wine

Crab Rangoon: From Classic Appetizer to Culinary Inspiration

5-Ingredient Meals: Culinary Magic Made Simple
Dining & Wine

5-Ingredient Meals: Culinary Magic Made Simple

Egg Substitutes: A Complete Guide for Baking and Cooking
Dining & Wine

Egg Substitutes: A Complete Guide for Baking and Cooking

Royal Recipes: Inside Meghan Markle's Culinary World
Dining & Wine

Royal Recipes: Inside Meghan Markle's Culinary World

Fun and Easy Recipes Kids Can Make Themselves
Dining & Wine

Fun and Easy Recipes Kids Can Make Themselves

Olive Oil Cake: A Simple Mediterranean Delight
Dining & Wine

Olive Oil Cake: A Simple Mediterranean Delight

NYC's Culinary Renaissance: 5 Must-Try Restaurants in 2024
Dining & Wine

NYC's Culinary Renaissance: 5 Must-Try Restaurants in 2024

Chicken Curry Laksa: A Culinary Masterpiece of Flavor and Color
Dining & Wine

Chicken Curry Laksa: A Culinary Masterpiece of Flavor and Color

Mapo Ragù Is an Ideal Wintertime Feast
Dining & Wine

Mapo Ragù Is an Ideal Wintertime Feast

Eleven Madison Park Granola: A Culinary Delight You Can Make at Home
Dining & Wine

Eleven Madison Park Granola: A Culinary Delight You Can Make at Home

Tofu: Your Protein-Packed Plant-Based Ally
Dining & Wine

Tofu: Your Protein-Packed Plant-Based Ally

Steak Fries: Deservedly Reviled or Underappreciated Edible Spoons?
Dining & Wine

Steak Fries: Deservedly Reviled or Underappreciated Edible Spoons?

Egg-cellent Alternatives: Delicious Breakfast Recipes with Fewer Eggs
Dining & Wine

Egg-cellent Alternatives: Delicious Breakfast Recipes with Fewer Eggs

Malört: From Chicago's Most Hated Shot to Midwest Icon
Dining & Wine

Malört: From Chicago's Most Hated Shot to Midwest Icon

Oregon's Underground Gold: The Truffle Boom
Dining & Wine

Oregon's Underground Gold: The Truffle Boom

Sunshine in a Bowl: The Ultimate Comfort Soup
Dining & Wine

Sunshine in a Bowl: The Ultimate Comfort Soup

Chicken Wellington: A Gourmet Twist on Classic Comfort Food
Dining & Wine

Chicken Wellington: A Gourmet Twist on Classic Comfort Food

Fresh Spring Veggie Pasta: 5 Delightful Meatless Recipes
Dining & Wine

Fresh Spring Veggie Pasta: 5 Delightful Meatless Recipes

Behind the Scenes: Laurie Woolever's Journey in Culinary Media
Dining & Wine

Behind the Scenes: Laurie Woolever's Journey in Culinary Media

Baking Without Eggs: Simple Swaps for Your Favorite Recipes
Dining & Wine

Baking Without Eggs: Simple Swaps for Your Favorite Recipes

Veggie Delights: Elevating Your Thanksgiving Feast in 2024
Dining & Wine

Veggie Delights: Elevating Your Thanksgiving Feast in 2024

In Defense of the Hard-Shell Taco
Dining & Wine

In Defense of the Hard-Shell Taco

LA Restaurants Rally as Wildfires Rage On
Dining & Wine

LA Restaurants Rally as Wildfires Rage On

Green Onions: Elevate Your Cooking with These Versatile Herbs
Dining & Wine

Green Onions: Elevate Your Cooking with These Versatile Herbs

The Ultimate Guide to NYC's Best Pizza Spots
Dining & Wine

The Ultimate Guide to NYC's Best Pizza Spots

Turkey Meatloaf: A Delicious Twist on a Classic Comfort Food
Dining & Wine

Turkey Meatloaf: A Delicious Twist on a Classic Comfort Food

Beyond Decor: The Real Taste of Dining Out
Dining & Wine

Beyond Decor: The Real Taste of Dining Out

The Ultimate Salmon Dish: A Culinary Masterpiece
Dining & Wine

The Ultimate Salmon Dish: A Culinary Masterpiece

Plant-Powered Party: A Vegetarian Feast That Impresses
Dining & Wine

Plant-Powered Party: A Vegetarian Feast That Impresses

That's a Wrap: The Art and Science of Sustainable Packaging
Dining & Wine

That's a Wrap: The Art and Science of Sustainable Packaging

Melissa Clark's Giant Jam Bun: A Delightful Twist on Classic Pastry
Dining & Wine

Melissa Clark's Giant Jam Bun: A Delightful Twist on Classic Pastry

The Magic Sauce That Saves Weeknight Dinners
Dining & Wine

The Magic Sauce That Saves Weeknight Dinners

Pierre Franey's Classic Turkey Chili: A Lighter Take on Comfort Food
Dining & Wine

Pierre Franey's Classic Turkey Chili: A Lighter Take on Comfort Food

Garlic: The Flavor-Packed Superfood That Transforms Chicken Dishes
Dining & Wine

Garlic: The Flavor-Packed Superfood That Transforms Chicken Dishes

The Perfect Pumpkin Pie: A Modern Take on a Thanksgiving Classic
Dining & Wine

The Perfect Pumpkin Pie: A Modern Take on a Thanksgiving Classic

Staying Up Late at the 24-Hour Diner
Dining & Wine

Staying Up Late at the 24-Hour Diner

Luv2Eat Thai Bistro: Where Authentic Flavor Meets Internet Fame
Dining & Wine

Luv2Eat Thai Bistro: Where Authentic Flavor Meets Internet Fame

Manhattan's Congestion Pricing: A New Challenge for Restaurant Industry
Dining & Wine

Manhattan's Congestion Pricing: A New Challenge for Restaurant Industry

No-Stress Overnight Oats: A Breakfast Lifesaver for Non-Morning People
Dining & Wine

No-Stress Overnight Oats: A Breakfast Lifesaver for Non-Morning People

5 Budget-Friendly Meals That Nourish Your Body and Wallet
Dining & Wine

5 Budget-Friendly Meals That Nourish Your Body and Wallet

Keema: The Ground Meat Dish That Transforms Ordinary Meals
Dining & Wine

Keema: The Ground Meat Dish That Transforms Ordinary Meals

The Meat Debate: More Than Just a Meal
Dining & Wine

The Meat Debate: More Than Just a Meal

Roasted Broccoli: From Boring to Brilliant
Dining & Wine

Roasted Broccoli: From Boring to Brilliant